The Best And Worst Free Agency Signing In NFL History

Football | 4/13/23

When the NFL free agency period starts, the money starts flying. Every team thinks that they have a shot at the Super Bowl and decide to spend a ton of cash on players they hope will make their team substantially better.

Some of these free agents will make their teams instantly more competitive, while other players are total busts. This article takes a deeper look into the biggest booms and busts of free agency in the NFL, and you're probably not going to believe where Ndamukong Suh falls. First, we're going to dive into the overspenders and garbage pickups.

Adam Archuleta

GettyImages-110383567
Sporting News/Sporting News via Getty Images
Sporting News/Sporting News via Getty Images

It might be hard to believe for some football fans, but there was a time that Adam Archuleta was the highest paid safety in the history of the NFL. While Archuleta isn't exactly a household name, the Washington Redskins still gave him a six-year, $30 million contract in 2007 before releasing him after only starting seven games.

He was picked up by the Chicago Bears, but Washington was forced to eat up a lot of his money in order to move him.

ADVERTISEMENT

Albert Haynesworth

ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-135363108
Grant Halverson/Getty Images
Grant Halverson/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

One of the most shocking free agency signings in the NFL was when the Washington Redskins signed Albert Haynesworth for seven years and $100 million in 2009.

ADVERTISEMENT

Prior to the signing, he had been one of the best defensive linemen in the game for the Tennessee Titans, but even at his best, he wasn't worth the money he was getting. Washington was hoping he would be the anchor to their defense, but once he got paid, he never recaptured that same drive to be the best.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jerry Porter

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-116612796
Kirby Lee/NFLPhotoLibrary
Kirby Lee/NFLPhotoLibrary
ADVERTISEMENT

The Oakland Raiders saw the writing on the wall with their wide receiver Jerry Porter and didn't bother signing him to an extension. Instead, the Jacksonville Jaguars swooped in and made one of the worst free agent deals of all time.

ADVERTISEMENT

They offered him a six-year, $30 million contract (that he probably wasn't even expecting at the time) and quickly showed he wasn't worth the price tag. He only lasted a single season with the Jags and had a mere 11 catches along the way.

ADVERTISEMENT

Neil O'Donnell

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-772454553
Harry How/Getty Images
Harry How/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Neil O'Donnell was the starting quarterback for the Pittsburgh Steelers when they were embarrassed in Super Bowl XXX. But, getting to the Super Bowl itself is quite a feat, and netted the QB a five-year, $25 million contract the following year with the New York Jets.

ADVERTISEMENT

Despite having a very high price tag, O'Donnell was a complete bust for the Jets and only completed one full season. In his defense, that season was marred with injuries and he only ended up starting six games.

ADVERTISEMENT

Jake Grove

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-89728126
NFL Photos / Getty Images
NFL Photos / Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

One might say that overpaying for an offensive lineman will never end well for your team, and the Miami Dolphins can attest to that. They threw a five-year, $29 million contract at Jake Grove after he finished his injury-plagued four seasons with the Oakland Raiders.

ADVERTISEMENT

Grove ended up only playing 12 games for the Dolphins before he got seriously injured and sat out the rest of the season. He was cut before the next season even began and the franchise had to eat up most of his money.

ADVERTISEMENT

Chuck Smith

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
chuck smith
Craig Jones /Allsport
Craig Jones /Allsport
ADVERTISEMENT

Chuck Smith was probably one of the biggest free agency picks up in the history of the NFL. He was the all-time leader in sacks and a Pro Bowl defensive end for the Atlanta Falcons, but decided to take his talents to the Carolina Panthers.

ADVERTISEMENT

He signed a five-year, $21 million contract, but ended up only playing two games with the Panthers in his first year due to injury. He retired by the end of that season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Dale Carter

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-53031667
Getty Images
Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Another day, another franchise left holding the bag after an awful free agency signing. This time, it comes in the form of a four-year, $22.8 million contract for Dale Carter from the Denver Broncos. As soon as he arrived in Denver his play saw a steep decline.

ADVERTISEMENT

He was known as a headache off of the field and that's exactly what he was with the Broncos. He was suspended by the league for a year for substance abuse and then he was released by the Broncos before the start of the next season.

ADVERTISEMENT

Antonio Bryant

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-113574502
NFL via Getty Images
NFL via Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Antonio Bryant was never someone who was known as a "locker room guy." In fact, he had a lot of people comparing his attitude to Terrell Owens, and at one point, he was cut from a team before the season even started.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Cinncinatti Bengals signed Bryant to a four-year, $28 million contract after knowing that he was basically a boom-or-bust type guy. Well, Bryant only lasted a year and, as was mentioned before, he got cut in training camp and released from the team.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ahman Green

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-120969364
Rich Gabrielson/NFLPhotoLibrary
Rich Gabrielson/NFLPhotoLibrary
ADVERTISEMENT

Ahman Green is one of the only running backs on this list because they're usually the players who have the least amount of transitioning to do with their new team. They don't have to build a rapport with a QB or wide receivers, and generally, aren't as grossly overpaid. But, Ahman Green was an exception to this.

ADVERTISEMENT

He led the NFL in rushing between 2000 and 2004, and signed a four-year, $23 million deal with the Houston Texans where he rushed for only 554 yards and five touchdowns in two seasons.

ADVERTISEMENT

Nnamdi Asomugha

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-179395280
Harry How/Getty Images
Harry How/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

This was a free agency mistake that many general managers at the time would've made. During the 2010 season, Nnamdi Asomugha was widely considered to be one of the most dominant cornerbacks in the league. The Oakland Raiders were unable to come up with the money needed to keep him, so the Philadelphia Eagles jumped in and signed him to a five-year, $60 million contract.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Eagles went 12-20 in the two seasons that Asomugha was on the team. He was released and picked up by the San Francisco 49ers.

ADVERTISEMENT

Andre Rison

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-158754589
George Gojkovich/Getty Images
George Gojkovich/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

When the Cleveland Browns signed Andre Rison in 1995, the fan base was incredibly excited. He was a four-time Pro Bowl wide receiver for the Atlanta Falcons and was showing even more potential than anyone had originally thought.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Browns signed him to a five-year, $17 million deal that at the time made him the highest paid wide receiver in NFL history. Rison ended up lasting only one season with the Browns, collecting 47 catches and was a non-factor in almost every game.

ADVERTISEMENT

Ndamukong Suh

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-1093432204
Elsa/Getty Images
Elsa/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Suh was one of the most dominant defensive linemen to ever play the game when he was with the Detroit Lions. Ndamukong Suh signed a deal in the spring of 2015 with the Miami Dolphins for six years and $114 million, with $60 million guaranteed. The deal made him the highest paid defensive player in NFL history.

ADVERTISEMENT

Suh only missed four games in three seasons with the Dolphins, but he certainly didn't play like the highest paid defensive player. He was never dominant and ended up becoming a huge distraction off the field for his new team.

ADVERTISEMENT

DeMarco Murray

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-893569196
Wesley Hitt/Getty Images
Wesley Hitt/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

DeMarco Murray was very productive during the first few years of his NFL career. That productivity was exactly what the Philadelphia Eagles' executives were looking for, and they ended up offering him a five-year, $40 million contract that he signed in the 2015 offseason.

ADVERTISEMENT

Murray's production ended up dropping to just 702 rushing yards in 2015 and the Eagles traded Murray to the Tennessee Titans the very next season. Obviously, he didn't end up living up to his contract.

ADVERTISEMENT

Matt Flynn

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-486399188
Rich Schultz /Getty Images
Rich Schultz /Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

There have been a lot of teams that have put a lot of their marbles in on a young quarterback hoping that he'll end up being the face of the franchise. There might not be a more relevant example than Matt Flynn in 2012. After being the backup QB to Aaron Rodgers and capitalizing on the very few chances he was given, the young backup was awarded a three-year, $20.5 million deal from the Seattle Seahawks.

ADVERTISEMENT

Flynn was so bad that he didn't even make it out of training camp. Russell Wilson was a rookie third-round pick in Seattle that year and outplayed Flynn by a wide margin. Flynn was cut by the time the season started.

ADVERTISEMENT

Peyton Manning

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-600666444
Justin Edmonds/Getty Images
Justin Edmonds/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Peyton Manning's leadership skills are one of the main reasons that he's considered as one of the best quarterbacks ever. Football fans were shocked when the Indianapolis Colts let Manning go into free agency without giving him a competitive deal to stay.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Colts wanted to go young and healthy with Andrew Luck, and the Denver Broncos only cared about winning. They did just that with Peyton leading their offense and it remains one of the best free agent signings of all time.

ADVERTISEMENT

Michael Turner

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-159570795
Scott Cunningham/Getty Images
Scott Cunningham/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Free agency and the NFL draft is generally full of running backs that were supposed to make a huge impact on their new team and failed. But, Michael Turner was certainly not a failure. Before signing with the Atlanta Falcons, he was the upcoming backup to LaDainian Tomlinson in San Diego.

ADVERTISEMENT

He came to Atlanta with some high expectations and he absolutely met these expectations. He finished his first season with 1,699 yards rushing (second in the league) and 17 touchdowns. He had two subsequent 1,000 yards rushing seasons right after that.

ADVERTISEMENT

Simeon Rice

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-77163898
Doug Pensinger/Getty Images
Doug Pensinger/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

The Tampa Bay Buccaneers added Simeon Rice and solidified their incredibly deep team. The Bucs already had one of, if not the best defenses in the league going into the season, so adding one of the leagues best pass rushers put them over the top.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rice recorded five straight seasons of double-digit sacks with the Bucs and was a very important part of the 2002 Super Bowl team that trounced the Oakland Raiders.

ADVERTISEMENT

Rod Woodson

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-477543077
Focus on Sport/Getty Images
Focus on Sport/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Rod Woodson was an 11-time Pro Bowler with the Pittsburgh Steelers in the 1990s. He was one of the biggest steals of free agency in NFL history when the Baltimore Ravens picked him up with a VERY modest contract in 1998.

ADVERTISEMENT

Woodson was part of the dominant defense that helped lead the Ravens to their first ever Super Bowl win. Steelers fans would always have a love for him, and he showed his affection for the franchise when he was inducted into the Hall of Fame as a Steeler.

ADVERTISEMENT

James Farrior

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-140716385
George Gojkovich/Getty Images
George Gojkovich/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

James Farrior never got the hype like his teammates like Troy Polamalu and Joey Porter, but he was an incredible addition to the Pittsburgh Steelers. He was drafted by the New York Jets and widely considered to be a bust by most of the league.

ADVERTISEMENT

He was picked up in the 2002 offseason by the Steelers and was basically a do-it-all linebacker for the next several seasons. He was a huge part of the Steelers defense that had Super Bowl wins in 2005 and 2007.

ADVERTISEMENT

Mike Vrabel

ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
GettyImages-82217569
Jim Rogash/Getty Images
Jim Rogash/Getty Images
ADVERTISEMENT

Mike Vrabel was a role player for the Pittsburgh Steelers who ended up being an absolute steal (no pun intended) for the New England Patriots. Bill Belichick doesn't get enough credit for his free agency pickups, but Vrabel instantly started making an impact in his first year.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Pats won three Super Bowls with Vrabel on the team, and he made touchdown receptions in both Super Bowl XXVIII and XXXIX. He became the first defensive player to score a touchdown in the Super Bowl since William "Refrigerator" Perry in Super Bowl XX.