Alex Rodriguez is one of the most successful MLB stars of all-time. He was the first player in league history to sign a contract worth more than $200 million, a stunning achievement he did twice! Off the field, his dating life has been filled with high-profile romances. From his most recent engagement to Jennifer Lopez to his rumored tryst with Madonna, these are the beautiful women Alex Rodriguez has dated!
Cynthia Scurtis: 2002 – 2008
Alex Rodriguez has been married once. His first and only wife was Cynthia Scurtis. The couple was together from 2002 until 2008 and first met at a gym in Miami, Florida. Two years after meeting, they welcomed their first child into the world – Natasha Alexander.
It wasn’t paradise, however, and after six years together, Scurtis filed for divorce, citing “emotional abandonment” in divorce filings.
Joslyn Morse: 2007
While Alex Rodriguez was still married to Cynthia Scurtis, rumors swirled that he was not the most faithful husband. In 2007, the NY Post spotted Rodriguez with Joslyn Morse, an exotic dancer in Las Vegas.
Sources told the publication that Rodriguez frequented the club Morse worked at, adding fire to the rumor mill. At the time, Scurtis stood by her husband, but one year later enough would be enough and the marriage would be over.
While the relationship between Alex Rodriguez and Madonna was never confirmed, the rumor was widespread enough to land her on this list. It was 2008 when they became close friends. Then, at similar times, they both got divorced, leading speculation to run rampant.
Even more interesting to the tabloids was the age difference between the two. Madonna is 17 years older than Alex Rodriguez, a large gap that was not unnoticed by the press driving the rumors!
Melissa Britos: 2008 – 2009
Alex Rodriguez was first spotted with model Melissa Britos on Valentine’s Day in 2009. They were dining at a fancy Italian restaurant in Miami Beach, meaning there were no rumors to this romance!
Rodriguez’s relationship with Britos was his first after divorcing from Cynthia Scurtis. It only lasted a year and would be the start of a series of short relationships for the embattled New York Yankees power-hitting franchise star. Just a week before the date, he admitted to having used steroids during the 2003 MLB season.
Bethany Frankel: 2009
The relationship between A-Rod and Real Housewives of New York reality television star Bethany Frankel didn’t last very long. Rodriguez was one year removed from his divorce at the time, while Frankel was 12 years removed from her own.
When asked about the relationship on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, Frankel played coy, saying, “What is used to date mean? I went out with him on two dates.” She also claimed to not remember if the two locked lips on either of their dates.
Kate Hudson: 2009
Continuing his 2009 adventures in dating, Alex Rodriguez briefly saw Kate Hudson. The romance ended because A-Rod reportedly couldn’t stop calling Madonna, and Hudson gave him an ultimatum.
A source revealed this to Daily Mail, “Kate was mad with jealousy. She gave A-Rod three chances to stop contacting Madonna. How would you feel if your new boyfriend kept calling his ex?” Just like he did a lot in the playoffs, A-Rod took all three chances and struck out.
Elaine Spottswood: 2009 – 2010
Kate Hudson’s three-strike rule might not have been the only reason she dumped A-Rod. Near the end of the couple’s relationship, he reportedly starting seeing model Elaine Spottswood. Spottswood comes from a real estate family and had been prominent in Hollywood circles before hooking up with Rodriguez
The couple dated until 2010, when A-Rod cut ties with her. Supposedly, he was overheard telling friends that Elaine was getting too clingy, so he had to end it.
Cameron Diaz: 2010 – 2011
After things went south with Elaine Spottswood, Alex Rodriguez moved on to actress Cameron Diaz. The Charlie’s Angel’s star was connected to the MLB star from 2010 until 2011. Diaz fell hard for Rodriguez, and when the couple split, she was left with a broken heart.
In 2012, Diaz revealed to InStyle, “When I was going through a bit of a heartbreak a little while ago, I said to a friend, ‘Wow, this really hurts!’ And he said to me, ‘That just shows you what your capacity for loving is.'”
Ella Magers: 2011
In 2011, Alex Rodriguez began dating fitness enthusiast and trainer Ella Magers. Before dating, Magers worked with the slugger on his training and nutrition plans. After his relationship with Cameron Diaz ended, the stars aligned for the pair to begin dating.
There were brief rumors that Magers is part of the reason Rodriguez and Diaz broke up, but it has never been confirmed. Either way, the relationship didn’t last very long as Magers and A-Rod broke up in November of 2011.
Torrie Wilson: 2011 – 2015
Rodriguez almost found true love for a second time with former WWE diva Torrie Wilson. The couple dated from 2011 until 2015, only breaking up because Rodriguez didn’t feel like he was ready to settle down again.
Unlike his romance with Diaz, this break-up didn’t leave anyone hurt. In 2015, Wilson also told TMZ that she and Rodriguez will always remain friends. She even planned to root for the Yankees that same year!
Demi Moore: 2012
Backtracking to 2012, it would appear Alex Rodriguez may not have always been faithful to Torrie Wilson. That year he was spotted with Demi Moore, who was freshly separated from Ashton Kutcher.
The duo shared a meal at The Lion in Manhattan, and even though they were with two other people, it didn’t stop the rumor mill from turning. Making matters more interesting, Moore is one of Madonna’s best friends.
Kyna Treacy: 2012
The same year Rodriguez flirted with Demi Moore, he made an evil bolder move to score a date with Australian model Kyna Treacy. He was playing in the American League Championship Series when he spotted her in the stands and tossed a baseball her way.
On the baseball, he wrote a message asking for her phone number. The bold move worked, and Rodriguez went on a date with Treacy. Was the date Torrie Wilson approved, though?
Julianne Hough: 2013
This fling only lasted one date, which reportedly didn’t go very well. The reason? Julianne Hough wasn’t even interested in going out with Alex Rodriguez, she just wanted to get revenge and make an ex-boyfriend jealous.
Rodriguez was seriously interested in Hough, and sources close to the star told the National Enquirer that he planned to pull out all the stops to impress her. Too bad she had other plans.
Erin Simmons: 2015
After officially ending things with Torrie Wilson on surprisingly good terms, Alex Rodriguez jumped right back into the dating pool. In the spring of 2015, he began seeing fitness enthusiast Erin Simmons.
Simmons, who is nearly 13 years younger than Rodriguez, attended Florida State where she starred in track has a Ph.D. in nutrition, and posts pictures of her workouts and diets on social media. Like most of A-rod’s relationships, this one didn’t last very long.
Anne Wojcicki: 2016 – 2017
For eleven months from 2016 until 2017, Alex Rodriguez dated Northern California biologist and 23andMe co-founder Anne Wojcicki. The couple was first spotted together in the spring of 2016 and were happy until February 2017, when they broke up.
Wojcicki’s mother was critical of Rodriguez after the break-up, saying he wasn’t smart enough to date her daughter. “He seemed to be genuinely in love with Anne. But I right away figured out this was a mismatch. He had no academic background. We couldn’t have an intellectual conversation about anything.”
Jennifer Lopez: 2017 – 2021
Alex Rodriguez and Jennifer Lopez first met at a Yankees game in 2005 but didn’t start dating until 2017. Once the romance was on, though, it was true love, so much so that Rodriguez even asked Lopez to marry him.
In May of 2019, the couple was officially engaged. Lopez would be Rodriguez’s second wife. Unfortunately, their love wasn’t meant to last, and after nearly two years of being engaged, Lopez called it all off in 2021.
Cynthia Scurtis Re-Married
Alex Rodriguez’s first and only wife, Cynthia Scurtis, is doing just fine today. Over a decade after divorcing the MLB star, Scurtis has found happiness with real estate advisor Angel Nicolas. The couple is married and shares one child together.
Scurtis also has a healthy relationship with A-Rod. The two have been photographed on multiple occasions co-parenting and smiling and laughing together. Things may have ended on a sour note, but now everything seems pretty sweet.
Bethany Frankel Got Engaged
In March of 2021, Bethany Frankel had some big news to reveal – she was engaged! Her husband-to-be is producer Paul Bernon, and he proposed with a ring valued at $1 million. The couple couldn’t be happier together.
Speaking with Extra, Frankel said she wasn’t quite sure whether the wedding would take place in New York, or somewhere more extravagant. Real Housewives of New York cast members weren’t as in love with the announcement as Frankel, claiming she purposely timed the news to happen at the same time as the trailer for the show’s new season came out.
Cameron Diaz Married A Rock Star
In 2014, Cameron Diaz was at a party hosted by Nicole Richie when she met Good Charlotte lead guitarist Benji Madden. There was an instant connection between the two, and one year later they tied the knot.
The two have been going strong ever since. Diaz even decided to step out of the limelight to focus on other pursuits. In 2020, the couple welcomed their first child into the world, a daughter they named Raddix.
Demi Moore Released A Memoir
Demi Moore’s divorce from Ashton Kutcher was finalized in 2013. The roller-coaster relationship left her in shambles, but today she’s doing better than ever. To help her cope with her past traumas, Moore wrote Inside Out, a memoir detailing her life and experiences.
The memoir was released in 2019 and revealed juicy details about her past romances with both Ashton Kutcher and Bruce Willis. As for Rodriguez, he didn’t make the cut of the publication.